10 Magical Gifts on Etsy to Charm Any Witch or Wizard


The holidays are right around the corner, and whether you’re a witch or wizard, Muggle or No-Maj, everyone can use a little help with their holiday shopping!

While I’m not opposed to shopping at popular chains or even sharing my favorite finds on Amazon, I do prefer shopping local and supporting small businesses when I can.


Related: Affordable Harry Potter Merchandise You Can Get on Amazon

With that in mind, this Harry Potter gift guide exclusively recommends magical gifts from Etsy! Shopping on Etsy is a great way to support small businesses no matter where you live around the world.

Harry Potter Gift Guide on Etsy

Everything recommended below has at least 100 reviews and at least an average of a 4-star rating. I’ve also done my best to limit my Harry Potter gift ideas to products that don’t infringe upon any trademark or copyright. It’s one thing to take inspiration from the wizarding world–it’s another thing to steal blatantly.

Note: This guide includes affiliate links. If you make a purchase, I might earn a small commission, at no cost to you. 

Custom Wizard Inspired Illustration Printable

This custom artwork is a bargain starting at just $25! Receive a family portrait with up to 7 subjects (including babies and pets!), each decked out in their Hogwarts House attire. You can choose to receive just a digital download of your original family portrait, or you can receive a printed copy.

Buy Custom Wizard Inspired Illustration on Etsy!

Wire Harry Potter Planner Clip Set

These wire clips are so cute! You can use them as bookmarks, paperclips, or even just fun decor for your desk. The set comes with an owl, a lightning bolt, a pair of glasses, a Golden Snitch, and the Deathly Hallows.

Buy Wire Harry Potter Planner Clip Set on Etsy!

The Sorting House Color Candle

This candle has 4 color choices and 2 scent options. Choose from Butterbeer or Hogwarts Christmas! If you already know your Hogwarts House, you can choose Yellow, Red, Blue, or Green. Or you can “get sorted” with a Sort Me candle!

Buy the Sorting Hat Candle on Etsy!

Acceptance Letter School of Witchcraft and Wizardry Personalized

Did your Hogwarts acceptance letter get lost in the mail? Don’t worry, you can get a beautiful letter from Etsy! This is completely personalized, with a birthday option, a Christmas option, and even a late option. (Yes, Hogwarts really did try to contact you when you were 11, but somehow the letter got lost!)

Oh, and if you want to surprise someone visiting one of the Wizarding World of Harry Potter theme parks, that’s an option too.

In addition, you can order add-on items like a train ticket, a class schedule, and even a beautiful Marauder’s Map.

This is truly a one-of-a-kind gift that will charm magical people of all ages!

Buy a Personalized Magical Acceptance Letter on Etsy!

Charm Bracelet (Blue Eagle House)

These charm bracelets are SO cute, and the colors are the actual canon Hogwarts House colors. If you’re a Ravenclaw, you know the struggle! This link is for the charm bracelet inspired by Ravenclaw, but you can also find bracelets inspired by the other Hogwarts Houses. The metal is stainless steel, which is hypoallergenic for most people.

Buy a Ravenclaw-Inspired Charm Bracelet on Etsy!

Favorite Place Favorite Wizards- Bronze on Royal Blue Shirt

Another great option for Ravenclaws who want to buy blue and bronze merch! Again, these t-shirts are inspired by all the Hogwarts Houses, but this particular listing is for the Ravenclaw-inspired t-shirt. The text says:

At My Favorite School with My Favorite Wizards

A great option for the whole family, these t-shirts could be a magical twist on matching outfits for family photos.

Buy a Hogwarts-Inspired T-Shirt on Etsy!

Wand Stylus

A few months ago, I wrote a detailed post comparing 3 Etsy shops who sell different styles of stylus wands. This weekend, I had the pleasure of meeting Naomi and Patrick of The Nifty Niffler, who sell beautiful wand styluses among other magical items.

I didn’t buy my own wand stylus, only because I plan on making one for myself. However, I did take the time to try out their stylus wands while playing Wizards Unite! I’m not accustomed to using a stylus, so it does take some adjusting to improve your spell-casting. However, by coincidence, two of my friends who always use styluses in Wizards Unite purchased stylus wands from The Nifty Niffler, and they really like the wand styluses!

You an even order a custom wand stylus that will be 3D-printed according to your preferences. Your wand stylus can even match your wand from Wizards Unite!

Buy a Wand Stylus on Etsy!

Wand Styluses

Winged Keys! Harry Potter Inspired Flying Keys

These gorgeous, handmade flying keys make great Christmas ornaments or even fun magical home decor to display year-round! The keys are solid metal, with plastic wings. You can buy a set of 5 flying keys or a set of 10 flying keys.

Buy Winged Keys on Etsy!

Harry Christmas Ornaments Felt

These little Harry Potter Inspired felt toys are so sweet! You can order them as simple toys, ornaments, or magnets. You can choose from the following designs (or buy them all!).

  • Harry (standing)
  • Harry (on a broom)
  • Hermione
  • Ron
  • Hedwig
  • Dumbledore
  • Voldemort

These cute toys are handmade with eco-friendly felt.

Buy Harry Potter Felt Toys on Etsy!

Spectrespecs Enamel Pin – Glitter Enamel Pin

This Etsy shop owner has a store filled with beautiful nerdy pins from original artwork! I absolutely love this pink and sparkly pin inspired by Luna Lovegood’s Spectrespecs. If it’s not your style, you can find other fun pins like a Dumbledore quote and a love potion bottle.

Buy a Spectrespecs Enamel Pin on Etsy!

Honestly, Etsy has so many great gift items for Harry Potter fans! Plus most Etsy shops are willing to ship worldwide, so this is a great option for all witches and wizards looking to buy unique gifts for their friends and family this holiday season.

If you’re looking for more gift ideas, I’ve put together multiple gift guides on my personal blog. Etsy also has multiple gift guides!

What’s on your holiday wish list this year?

0 0 votes
Article Rating
Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments